Current:Home > ScamsNorth Dakota Supreme Court strikes down key budget bill, likely forcing Legislature to reconvene -WealthMindset Learning
North Dakota Supreme Court strikes down key budget bill, likely forcing Legislature to reconvene
View
Date:2025-04-18 03:29:22
BISMARCK, N.D. (AP) — The North Dakota Supreme Court struck down a major budget bill for the state government on Thursday, likely meaning lawmakers must come back to Bismarck to do the massive bill over again.
The court ruled the bill “was unconstitutionally enacted and is void” because it violates a provision of the state constitution that says bills can’t embrace more than one subject. The budget bill traditionally contains numerous other items, such as corrections, which are usually hammered out in the session’s last days in April.
Republican Senate Majority Leader David Hogue said in an interview Thursday that “it’s fair to say” the Legislature will need to reconvene.
The state’s highest court was asked to rule on the budget bill because of a lawsuit brought by the board overseeing North Dakota’s government retirement plans. The budget bill included a change that increased lawmakers’ membership on the board from two to four, a move the board sought to void. The board argued it’s unconstitutional for state lawmakers to sit on the panel.
“Invalidation of (the bill) as a whole is required here,” Justice Daniel Crothers wrote, “because we do not know which provisions were primary and which were secondary, or whether the bill would have been enacted absent the presence of any of the many sections.”
Top lawmakers, including Republican majority leaders and the chairs of budget writing committees, sat on the House-Senate panel that negotiated the budget bill’s final version, which was the last bill passed this year.
Chief Justice Jon Jensen concurred with Crothers, writing separately for a stay of 30 days for the Legislature to respond due to the invalidation’s “far-reaching consequences.” He made clear that the opinion “has ramifications far beyond the issue raised by the Board, and invalidates all of the legislation included within” the budget bill.
Justice Lisa Fair McEvers agreed that not granting lawmakers extra time could have unintended negative effects.
“The funding for much of state government is called into question by declaring the legislation invalid — including funds that have already been spent,” McEvers wrote.
Hogue said, “The Office of Management and Budget does not have funding to operate. The entire bill was invalidated, so they’ve got to be able to function.”
Republican House Majority Leader Mike Lefor said he hadn’t yet read the court’s opinion but planned to discuss its ramifications with fellow lawmakers and legislative staff to figure out what to do next.
“What we’re going to need to do is be transparent, thoughtful and deliberate in the thought process so that we can best move forward as the legislative body,” he said in an interview.
Republican Gov. Doug Burgum in a statement said he is arranging meetings with legislative leaders for how to best respond.
The Legislature could reconvene using the five days remaining from its 80-day constitutional limit to meet every two years to pass new laws. Also, Burgum, who is running for president, could call a special session.
veryGood! (58)
Related
- The White House is cracking down on overdraft fees
- The secret to Barbie's enduring appeal? She can fend for herself
- Boats, bikes and the Beigies
- Twitter threatens to sue its new rival, Threads, claiming Meta stole trade secrets
- Highlights from Trump’s interview with Time magazine
- How Climate Change Influences Temperatures in 1,000 Cities Around the World
- See Timothée Chalamet Transform Into Willy Wonka in First Wonka Movie Trailer
- Feeling Overwhelmed About Going All-Electric at Home? Here’s How to Get Started
- 'Survivor' 47 finale, part one recap: 2 players were sent home. Who's left in the game?
- A Timber Mill Below Mount Shasta Gave Rise to a Historic Black Community, and Likely Sparked the Wildfire That Destroyed It
Ranking
- Are Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp down? Meta says most issues resolved after outages
- How a New ‘Battery Data Genome’ Project Will Use Vast Amounts of Information to Build Better EVs
- Legacy admissions, the Russian Ruble and Final Fantasy XVI
- The black market endangered this frog. Can the free market save it?
- New Zealand official reverses visa refusal for US conservative influencer Candace Owens
- Protesters Rally at Gas Summit in Louisiana, Where Industry Eyes a Fossil Fuel Buildout
- The secret to Barbie's enduring appeal? She can fend for herself
- Fox News hit with another defamation lawsuit — this one over Jan. 6 allegations
Recommendation
Whoopi Goldberg is delightfully vile as Miss Hannigan in ‘Annie’ stage return
Legacy admissions, the Russian Ruble and Final Fantasy XVI
Fox pays $12 million to resolve suit alleging bias at Tucker Carlson's show
Get Shiny, Frizz-Free, Waterproof Hair With These 30% Off Color Wow Deals From Amazon Prime Day 2023
In ‘Nickel Boys,’ striving for a new way to see
The FTC is targeting fake customer reviews in a bid to help real-world shoppers
To tip or not to tip? 3 reasons why tipping has gotten so out of control
Tom Cruise and Son Connor Cruise Make Rare Joint Outing Together in NYC